Sunday, September 24, 2006

Libraries as Doors

A competition brief for City of Stockholm public library:
“Libraries should be door-openers showing visitors new ways of learning and experiencing, as well as maintaining and reinforcing their own cultural capital in a variety of ways.” [Added italics].
Contrast that with this comment from Raynata:

"... Have you gone the library now? Now we've to leave all our stuff in the locker... "

in this posting. In this case, the library is door-closers showing visitors only one way of learning and experiencing: you have to belong to the university and you must relinquish all your belongings to access it :)

A --> B =/= B --> A













A crop of an ad in Kompas: This is Jakarta!

Travelling time from point A to point B is often not equal from point B to point A. Look at the difference in time between weekdays and weekends!

Friday, September 22, 2006

Intuition to Dwell

Last term, I taught architectural design studio in which students were challenged to create personal space for themselves. Piece of cake, as we all have innate spatial ability as discussed in this previous posting – right? But as it turned out, not many students could create space that was in the least comfortable. I tried to go in and out of some of their constructions, and I could have broken or hurt my neck or other parts of my body if I weren’t mindful.

So why is it, while human ability to gauge and utilize space is innate, yet, most architectural students (at least those I’ve worked with) are having a hard time creating space?

Several possible reasons, but I’ll start with one: the lack of trust in the realm of our intuition. When we learn about a subject matter in university, suddenly the subject we’re interested in becomes a discipline with fields of “experts” that we consider know better about the discipline. The theories, lectures and discussions - some of which we may understand, but more often make us feel even more incompetent - overwhelmed our senses. The result is the lack of trust in what we see, what we feel, what we hear, what we touch, what we taste. We lose our intuition, our innate human ability, and belief in self.

That’s the reason why I am fascinated by construction of space created by traditional communities, by those living in adverse conditions, by those who adapted spaces and constructions of every day life to fit their needs. Through them, we are reminded why space is designed in the first place: to shelter and comfort our body. To be our third skin. Apart from that, these type of constructions are most likely constrained by available materials, by their surroundings (the site), and therefore attempt to create the most optimal solution for the problem.

The child in this photograph could have slept in many other places other than in the cart. Yet, the cart was the optimal solution for the problem. The cart raised the child’s body from the asphalt road – removed her from heated asphalt and dirt, from being accidentally trampled on, and from being awakened by animals that might have wondered by her. The cardboard box provided her with added cushion to support and comfort her sleeping body. And she can still be supervised by an adult who brought her there in the first place. The most optimal solution for taking a nap in public place.

A classic book in this topic is “Architecture without Architects” by Bernard Rudofsky.

Thursday, September 21, 2006

Does Design Matter?

I was struck by this photograph of a child published in Kompas (19 September 2006, p.3). She was sleeping in a cardboard box in a cart. And I thought to myself: how fit she was to the space she occupied. This photograph proves that the ability of human to gauge and utilize space is innate. Human also has high capacity to adapt. When we are tired, we will immediately scan our surrounding to look for places where we can sit: a chair, a step, a fallen pole, an upside down drum, a stone. And when we can’t find anything, the earth would do.

It seems that our survival instict will enable us to adapt to any kind of spaces we are in. Under adverse condition, as in the case of the homeless, people will find a way out and think creatively – see here for another example.

And I wonder: does (architectural) design matter?

Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Plan-less: Heaven for the Homeless


Adi Purnomo (a.k.a. Mamo), an architect who authored “Relativitas” and won numerous awards to say the least, asked me to collaborate with him to work on Shinkenchiku Residential Design Competition 2006. Below is my only contribution to the so-called collaboration, some parts were inspired by our discussions, while others are direct translations of Mamo’s writings. Image is courtesy of Mamo.

Scorching heat on undulating asphalts
Dirt and rocks, unfriendly concrete pavements
Passing cars and motorcycles: Be careful, these roads are not yours!

I am here!
Walking
Scanning every meters of the streets
Trying to find scraps of materials I can reuse

Shade: Cover my restless, dehydrated body from the tropical sun
Let me sit on your threshold
Let me lie under your canopy
Let me watch the world go by
Thinking: How could I feed myself today?

Water: Drench the crevices of my organs
Clear my spirit before my feet lead me on to other urban nooks and expanses
But spare me from your overflowing angst

I am a residue of a sprawling, rhizomatic Jakarta
I roam its spaces with my senses
I stop or turn, work or rest, sit or sleep, walk or run, whenever my feet tells me to
Whenever I am conditioned to
Whenever these spaces invite me to

The street lamps. Starless, smoggy night
Immortal fireflies composing a skyline
I am finally at peace with this metropolis
I roam its streets as free as a bird, soaring towards heaven

I am uprooted, but I am one with Jakarta
The universe is in my palm
My house is everywhere
My home is in my heart
Plan-less, as is my life